"How did these items get made if there's no way to learn magic? Are the magicians homeschooling their children and not writing any books? How did you learn?"
"Half this stuff is antiques," says the shopkeep. "Look, asking me a dozen times isn't gonna make the answer more to your liking. I don't have Hogwarts in the basement, deal with it."
"But where do you get the stuff that isn't antique - who made the Avalon itself? - isn't anybody panicking about the medallion supply? -"
"Kid, nobody knows how to make medallions."
"But some people apparently know how to make luck charms and protection amulets!"
"I'm not going to give out my suppliers' personal information. I wouldn't do it even if you weren't annoying."
"There have to be books -"
"Does this look like a library to you?"
"He doesn't have any explanation for where any of his stuff comes from," says the girl in the wheelchair, "which is enough to make me suspect that it's not magical at all except possibly the medallions -"
"Hey, none of that! It's legitimate merchandise, just because I don't run a fu- a darn university in my storefront you're calling me a fraud? I should throw you out for that!"
"I confess that I myself have only recently come into the awareness of magic at all, and the only verifiable magic I have personally observed--besides the Avalon itself, now--is my sister's friend's medallion. And countless others, I'm sure, since entering this place. What else, precisely, is magic supposed to be able to do?"
"- with no user manuals or explanation of the principles behind them and they don't so much as glow -"
"I will throw you out, young lady. Are you like this at the Radio Shack?"
Wheelchair girl snorts.
"Anyway, I've got stuff that does glow, too, doesn't need batteries, prettier than a flashlight; got a knife that stays sharp, only one though; got a magic timepiece; got nixie essence; oh, and a little magic fan. Plus your standard array of medallions and one blank, I see two've you don't have yours."
"...I don't know that we are anything other than human," he says, as though it hadn't occurred to him, "but then apparently Daphne didn't either before a month ago. I suppose it's worth checking, at any rate." He shrugs. "I can certainly see why someone would be...skeptical...of a luck charm of unknown provenance. To be quite frank, it seems like the sort of thing that would be rather difficult to tell even once you had it, unless it produced some rather dramatic results."
"You might have said that," complains wheelchair girl.
"It's nothing to do with how they're made, you were on about how they were made," he sniffs. "Anyway, you can try the medallions but if one turns you, you buy it, no installments no layaway no discounts."
To the girl in the wheelchair: "Is there any particular reason you thought he'd know how they were made? Not that I wouldn't dearly love to learn too, but in my experience shopkeepers and artisans aren't often the same person."
"I can tell you they're not mass-produced. I'd be sending you to people's houses, not a good business practice," snorts the shopkeep.
"How did you find people with magic things to sell?" she wheedles.
"Some of 'em were already selling to here when my mother ran the place, some of 'em came to me, I don't take out ads in the paper about it!"
"Can most people not do magic, does it only run in families or something?"
"Not as far as I know," shrugs the shopkeep.
"Then why isn't this Harry Potter, at least as far as having a magical school is concerned?"
"Nobody's started one?" the shopkeep asks, as though this is a deeply stupid question.
"I don't think it's as dire as all that."
"Then you ought to be able to convince me of that, oughtn't you?"
Eyeroll.
"I don't suppose you have any helpful information?"
"Yes, I suppose. I can do the steps if I have to," sighs wheelchair girl. "Although really it's only a matter of time before someone who's genuinely paralyzed from the waist down turns out to be a critter, so it's still irresponsible." She wheels for the door. The shopkeep doesn't bother to tell them to come again another time.
"I found out I was a firebird under kind of awkward circumstances, and then I met Jaromira a while later, and we just kind of--clicked. And she was a sympathetic ear who wasn't close enough to the situation to make it weird, and then of course she told her brother everything--about critters and magic and stuff I mean, not the personal stuff I told her--and it turns out he's kind of a huge fantasy geek, and the idea that magic was real, well."
"It's a pleasure to meet you, even under the circumstances. Perhaps especially under the circumstances. I think I'd not have inquired after educational possibilities for some time had you not been there." He snorts. "'Institutional shambles' may be too kind. Had there been an institution in the first place for there to be shambles of there would at least be some historical precedent for finding teachers."
When they've crossed the park and reached the bookstore, May says, "Could one of you hold the door for me so I can haul the chair up the steps?"
She gets out of her chair, hand firmly on the railing; takes the two steps up; and pulls her chair after her. When it is in the bookstore she sits again.
There is one copy of a book called Runecasting and two, one clearly used, of Abridged Runic Dictionary.
"...How annoyed are you three going to be if I just. Take these," says May, grabbing the lone Runecasting and the used dictionary.
"...The amount of money I can draw on without Father asking questions I'd rather not answer doesn't cover a medallion but it would cover those books. If I bought them for you would you be willing to do some kind of time-share on the one there's only one copy of? We could meet--somewhere public, of course, I'm all but a stranger--say once a week to exchange it and discuss? Having a teacher doesn't seem to be on the table, but having someone else to learn with seems worthwhile."
She grabs Imaginary, Extinct, Hiding and 500 Historical Figures and also Avalons Around the World and puts them in her lap under the magic books. Roll roll. At the till Kanimir gets the top two volumes to pay for.
"Nothing's wrong with my legs in particular. My diagnosis is so vague you could drive a really clumsy monster truck through it, but it's probably neurological, and it'd affect my arms enough too if I decided I wanted to try wheelchair basketball but thankfully doesn't affect my handwriting or ability to brush my hair or anything like that. I could probably get by without the wheelchair if I were really determined and masochistic, except in wintertime - and since I have to have one to get anywhere in wintertime, I bust it out whenever I feel like it."
"Yep." Ah look, one of those park chess tables, unoccupied by chess. May rolls up to the side of it rather than transfer onto the bench, and plunks down the magic books and a notebook produced from the bag on the back of her chair. "All right, let's see what runecasting is all about."
It turns out May reads very fast but also believes in heavy notetaking. Runecasting (as she notes, due to it being what the book says) is about drawing designs and then saying things to the designs in foreign languages. It is important to use foreign languages or you'll overpower the spell and maybe die; it is important to say the entire thing you were going to say or you will "eat" the spell and maybe die; it is important to draw the design right or you will fuck up the spell and maybe die. Side effects of fucking up spells and not dying include turning into a critter, possibly a novel kind, if you were not one already - or, if you were, becoming a new sort of critter and disconnecting from your medallion and thereafter being (technically speaking) "a monster".
It goes into quite a lot of detail about how runecasting is really dangerous and you probably shouldn't do it without supervision.
"Pfft," May says when she gets to that part. "Yeah, no problem, we can run down to the Hogwarts the magic shop guy keeps in his basement and get supervision there, it'll be easy."
Kanimir is also a fast reader and a firm believer in heavy notetaking! "I suppose having each other to check our work is better than nothing, but yes, safety precautions are rather useless when they don't tell you how to find the blasted safety measure. Perhaps this was written in a more friendly time." He checks the publication date.
She turns a page, which describes "circumscriptions": the shapes that surround the rest of a spell design. By default, these are rectangles or squares, although other shapes can be used. May starts a chart.
Charts. Kanimir adds a note to his reminding himself to look up the etymology of the word circumscription, since it apparently doesn't need to have anything to do with circles.
It may have to do with all the magical design terms having -scription in them. Later pages refer to "description" (the runes describing the positive effect of the spell), "proscription" (cancellations for unwanted effects of versatile symbols), and "superscription" and "subscription" (effectively, footnotes for the major runes). The author likes to call the words you speak to cast a spell "inscriptions" and the entire process of spell development or copying "scribing", too.
One such note suggests he look up other runic alphabets and check for similarities between those and the magic kind of rune. "I wouldn't necessarily bother," he says ruefully when he sees her looking, "but there's little enough information readily available; I'd like to see if I can find anything useful elsewhere."
Page turn. More principles of rune arrangement. The author is not being particularly restrained in which runes she uses in her examples and has not actually explained what any of them do - it comes up only incidentally ("marking ᛟ in the proscription will cancel the 'human target' effect of 'ᛗ'"). She acknowledges this once in a footnote, remarking that being a runic dictionary is outside the scope of her project but that she will cover how to derive new runes in chapter eight.
May doggedly looks up all the runes as they come up. Every one has an array of effects, defined in units that it seems the runic dictionary author made up entirely - á›— apparently has a 'human target' effect of 9.7, for example, as one of eight properties it's listed as having. This is when it's one centimeter tall; all of the runes' effect sizes are defined when they are one centimeter tall. Scaling them up or down affects all of their results proportionately, which is how there's any hope of balancing anything - but except for a couple of toy examples in the textbook, it looks like most spells need layers of proscriptions and superscriptions and subscriptions six and seven layers deep to get unwanted effects down to safe levels. (Safety of levels is apparently defined relative to the size of the spell, not the absolute length of the runes - this is because a single chant puts a fairly consistent amount of total power into the spell, and 3% of it going astray will generally not hurt anything even if the design is six feet wide and 3% is at a level of 458 or something.)
"You know what this all wants," May says, "is a fancily programmed spreadsheet. I'll start one tonight."
"Definitely. Actually, I wonder if we could just print a thusly constructed spell--it says here you can't cast out of the book but I don't know if that's because printing doesn't work or because someone pre-used the spells to make it harder for novices to hurt themselves with them or for some other reason."
"Good question. I can swing by my mom's school after mine lets out and swipe her copier, if there turns out to be anything in here we actually want to test." The toy examples they have seen so far would, if cast, explode an inanimate object of more than two tons, set the entire diagram on fire, and turn a rat into a pigeon, respectively; they were chosen for their illustrative runic characteristics and not practicality. May makes a note of this contingent to-do item.
"See you tomorrow?" May says, when they come to the end of it.
"Mm. An unpromising research avenue. This book doesn't have dates in it to compare to likely origin points for various legends--given that new critters can apparently come into existence if you mess up a spell, I've been trying to see whether some of them were inspired by legends rather than vice-versa. But I'm afraid I'm not really getting anywhere with that."
"Haven't gotten to that chapter in the book yet, but if I had to guess perytons emerged sometime after most of the legends got established and were better at hiding than other critters, until around then. I'd say it was a complete coincidence - somebody would have thought of mashing up a bird with a deer eventually - if it weren't for the names matching. That could just be the guy who published the book knowing someone who knew about critters and suggesting the term, though."
"...There could be written instructions left somewhere. In someone's tomb or forgotten library or abandoned workshop or something. I wonder if anyone's thought it a priority to check to find out." He purses his lips. "Even if they don't now they probably have at some point in the past...I wonder if it would be possible to create a spell to reconstruct destroyed nonmagical objects..."
"Yeah. It should be okay, though, my impression hasn't been that fluency per se is terribly important and if we're doing it right we won't need to invent incantations on the spot, just say them without stuttering. Oh, for the spreadsheet, I couldn't type ninety eight percent of the runes I got through so they're all page number in the dictionary and letter - first one is 6-A since there's the front matter in pages one through five, and on from there."
It can matter what you scribe your inscriptions on and with. Not, usually, because the material changes the spell, but because it can throw off your runes if you carve them in jello or drizzle them in mustard. They need to have straight lines and good curves. Standard rune construction involves a compass and straightedge; it is permissible to use a protractor; final designs should all be in a single material to allow the magic to ignore compass markings and stray pencil smudges; you should be sure your pen does not drip or jitter, and that it won't tear the paper (this can have unpredictable and therefore sometimes fatal results). If drawing on the ground it is advisable to use larger runes so that small irregularities make up a smaller fraction of each symbol.
Back to the chapter. Anything written or drawn outside the main circumscription will not affect the spell, unless you're doing one with two diagrams (chapter six); it is customary to write your inscriptions (incantations) down so you don't forget them mid-sentence; they should be about yea long and yea complicated and yea exact; here are some examples in various languages, Polish alas not among them but French is in there.
"Oooooh, I wanna turn invisible," sighs May. "And fly to school."
Textbook. Principles of how to compactly arrange runes and in what order. Spatial location of runes has a variety of fuzzy effects on spells that the author burns a lot of words trying to explain without getting very far. She does repeatedly assert that one develops a feel for it and it's mostly only a problem with particularly gargantuan or high-precision spells.
Here is a section of two chapters in a row about what the one- and two-word summaries of rune function mean in more detail, and cases where two runes may be listed as having one aspect alike but actually differ in crucial ways unless all of their other effects are totally suppressed.
("Maybe this author just really likes fire.")
"Well, that was more fiddly than I was fantasizing but not as bad as it could have been," May says, shutting the book. "I think the best example spell to try is probably the one that boils water. I mean, it could kill us, but any spell could and boiling water unlike fire has a fixed temperature. Monday I can bring a run-off copy."
"I--um--" He takes a deep breath. "You're intelligent and creative and interesting and you have a really pretty smile, and obviously if you're not interested that's fine, or anyway it should be obvious and I'm not one of those jackasses who thinks they somehow deserve any kind of attention from someone else that they're not interested in giving, but--if you were interested--I--"
Pause.
"So, um--I try not to be ostentatious about it, but my family does have money. Is this the kind of thing where you're happy to help me get back at my insufficient father by spending his money, or where you want to not feel like we're conforming to outdated gender roles, or something else?"
"I sort of get it? Restaurants in particular have brutal margins and it's hard to get investors. If they can't put together enough capital to be picky about buildings or refit them," shrug, "I mean, it's not like they're hedging me out for being Asian, if they were doing that a pox on the lot of them because it's strictly more effort. What's really enraging is when the elevators in train stations are broken. And stay that way for weeks. And the one thing that sets me off every time is when a total stranger sees me stand up and wants to know everything about my medical history, as though I didn't increase aggregate demand for wheelchairs and thus improve the market. It's like they think I stole it from a paraplegic."
"You were fine. The average case is someone I wasn't even talking to in the first place, who jumps straight to chiding me. Or yanking my chair away while I'm standing up. I don't even park in handicapped spots," snorts May, "which would almost earn a little suspicion over a scarce resource, if the people who take it on themselves to be the wheelchair police weren't such jerks."
He shrugs. "In my experience, when someone has to deal with something unpleasant frequently, even experiences that would otherwise be innocuous can become grating, if they're similar. It didn't turn out to be necessary, but I would prefer to be more curious rather than less. To the extent my curiosity allows, I suppose, or I would have refrained from bringing it up altogether."
"Believe me, I understand being curious. This is also the reason why I find a reason to mention that I'm Japanese early in an acquaintance if I can. Because it's not clear when people are supposed to ask, but it would be weird if someone knew me for four years and thought maybe I was Mongolian or something."
"Part of the circumstances are that Daphne was spending most of her emotional energy dealing with the aftermath of her first transformation. She..." he trails off. "It isn't my place to tell the whole story, but when she acquired her medallion, it led to some other things becoming known that were harder to deal with."
"It does sound fun. Wyverns seem like the best thing to be, to be honest. Various kinds of avians as well, but I prefer scales to feathers. I'd say dragons if they weren't extinct, probably." He pauses, going over what he just said and winces. "...In terms of, you know, fun--please don't tell anyone I just said that, it must sound terribly speciesist or something."
"Under the circumstances, I think it would be unwise to assume it wasn't. Knowing less about the culture means I ought to be more careful, not less." After a moment he adds, "I don't think I'd mind fur or feathers either. I find scales more aesthetic, but I wouldn't be displeased with feathered wings."
"My first thought is that immortality ought to be considered a higher priority than nearly anything else, since of course if we have forever then we can achieve everything else. But of course if it were within the reach of a pair of novices then someone would surely have let it slip by now. Perhaps some form of healing, to build up to that eventually, or a locating spell, so we can eventually find out if there's any lost information on the medallion creation process still intact."
"Yeah, healing would be my answer. I think it's unlikely that we'll get outright permanent invulnerability to death in general. I've been reading up on the extinction war and there's no inkling that anybody had that, even at the height of magical knowhow, so it'd probably wind up being at most anti-aging unless we're lucky enough to be unprecedented prodigies - and we're a little young to need that urgently. A locating spell's a good idea." Write write.
"Yeah. The dictionary's abridged, even. I wonder if there's a rune for every possible combination of things? If there is then with sufficiently exhaustive derivation you could not only waste your entire life hunched over graph paper but also cast useful single-rune spells."
"I could understand turning down immortality if literally only one person could become immortal, on the grounds that outliving one's loved ones would be too painful, especially if by deferring immortality someone more inclined could take it up instead, but there are an alarmingly large number of books where the immortality itself is considered a negative in its own right."
"I usually choose to interpret the moral as 'sacrificing others and damaging your own mind because you were too paralyzed by your fear of death to refrain from going with the first option presented rather than doing research into more palatable options is a really terrible plan.'"
"Yes. This is a world with the philosopher's stone in it and supposedly Voldemort's really academically talented and the last guy who pulled it off is still alive to be asked nicely for tutoring, and he doesn't, say, research alchemy and make his own, he runs off and uses some strictly inferior option and kills a bunch of people."
"So the moral is to not let fear of something prevent you from taking the correct rather than immediate solution. It even fits with Harry's dementor experiences in the third book." Pause. "I remain firmly convinced, for the record, that the Flamels faked breaking the stone, got plastic surgery or some wizarding equivalent, and moved abroad rather than actually allowing themselves to die. Really, there's no reason not to."
"Well, he was remarkably intelligent and very powerful, and he defeated the last Dark Lord before Voldemort. He's probably a useful person to know if, say, you have something extremely valuable that you periodically need to hide." beat "And then of course instead of storing it somewhere no one but the Hogwarts Headmaster could get to he put it behind an easily-bypassed series of traps with 'MacGuffin within' written on it in metaphorical neon signage, they got fed up with his bullshit and faked their eventual deaths."
"Well, it's not clear if Voldemort could have gotten it out of the mirror if Harry didn't go and do it for him," May says. "The traps leading up to it were not particularly well-thought-out, but the object wasn't 'have difficult traps', it was 'conceal stone'. ...Though it seems like a jerk move to store an object for your friends which they regularly use in a way that prevents them from going and getting it; what if Dumbledore had died? And I'm not about to defend Dumbledore in general, he's complicit in child abuse and educational sabotage."
"The problem with the way the Stone was stored is that 'to keep it away from the villain' is not the only reason to want it besides using it. If Voldemort had sent a loyal minion with whom he was not physically attached, they wouldn't have wanted it to use it, they would have wanted it to deliver it to their dread master."
"Quirrel tried it before Harry got there, but since Voldemort was co-occupying his body Quirrel would have had to use the stone for Voldemort to benefit. If he had sent a different minion--which he didn't have contact with at the time, I will admit, but I'm dubious that Dumbledore was sufficiently sure of that to justify the loophole. More to the point, I'm dubious whether the Flamels would be satisfied with the setup, which is an entirely different question."
"Probably if they knew any details about how Dumbledore proposed to hide their most important rock they would have said 'no, we would rather just rely on Voldemort's inability to remember that there is a world outside of Europe and usually just Britain, we will be in Chile if you need us'."
"Of course, I am sort of disappointed in them for not - having safely stashed the stone somewhere - doing more with their six centuries and change of experience and knowhow to help with all the appalling things going on. Maybe they got up to similar shenanigans in Chile and Harry and Dumbledore and so on share Voldemort's myopia about the rest of the globe and we just never heard about it."
"Or something that'd give me a softer landing. But just not hitting the ground wouldn't get me all the way to skating around on ice - I'd just fall repeatedly on the same patch - so it wouldn't get me out of the chair so it doesn't seem like a research priority unless a complete fix presents itself."
Kanimir makes a mental note to go over the dictionary again with this in mind just in case some inspiration does present itself. "True enough. Similar principles might be useful for physical defense, though...but we're not any likelier than average to get hit by cars or suffer other forms of accident. That's not none, though. I think I had better put that on the list."
"I haven't opened it yet," she says. "I thought you'd want to see. Wax is a good idea, I had been thinking of linoleum - the wax might deform if you toted it around but it's an easier carving job and you could stamp a few tablets with a mold if it turns out to work. Smart. Boiling first or correspondence?"
Dear Ms. Swan,
The author of 'Runecasting' passed away in 1985, unfortunately, and is not available to receive your compliments; her estate prefers not to have mail forwarded. The book is out of print but if you are interested in buying a second copy we have a handful in our warehouse; a check for $30 (USD) made out to Medallion Books will cover book and shipping if you still want a second copy. There are no other texts in the series, we regret to inform you, although we do print-on-demand an unabridged runic dictionary ($75 USD for three volumes). As to your other questions, we are unable to assist.
Sincerely,
Moira Stein, VP, Medallion Books
"If my father asks what I'm spending money on I can honestly say books; he won't inquire further. Spending amounts of money similar to this on more mundane books is something I've been known to do. I was concerned about the medallions because it was so much at once that I would have no plausible excuse for."
She puts the kettle on a Xeroxed spell.
"Do you want to do it or shall I?"
He's had the incantation memorized since not long after they settled on this spell, but he still glances at the scroll he's attempting to use as he says, "I command that this water before me boil at once."
Nothing happens.
"...I guess photocopies don't work," he says ruefully.
"So last night I got a little ahead of myself and I compiled a list of meanings - not runes, just meanings - that I think would go well in an invisibility spell, but I think you should do something similar on your own so we can compare without you being contaminated by my ideas."
Kanimir takes the tablet over to where May filled the kettle, rinses it out, decides the day's balmy enough he doesn't need a sweater, takes his off, and dries it. Then he carries it back over to the table, puts the kettle (currently containing warm but not boiling water) on the tablet, and incants again.
"Well, yes, I suppose it is. Having a few on hand just in case doesn't seem like a bad idea...my sister could certainly be trusted with one, and almost certainly Daphne as well. The most mischief I expect those two to get up to with the power of invisibility is more discreet public displays of affection, and Daphne could certainly use it for the same purpose as yourself, namely greater freedom of movement." He pauses. "I wonder if it mightn't be possible to create some kind of invisibility that only worked while in fullform, so that other winged critters could enjoy similar."
"That sounds harder, and an invisibility object is already a job and a half compared to an invisibility one-time spell, which we don't know how to do yet - but long term, maybe, although an invisible griffin has many of the same questionable applications as an invisible shapeshifter or invisible human."
"It would at least be harder to do things like invade the privacy of attractive members of one's preferred gender in washrooms, which is what most of my peers seem likely to do given the chance to abuse invisibility, but quite. Perhaps some kind of service for casting one-time invisibility spells so they can at least go flying outside of an Avalon for a little while would be a good idea."
"Whether that's a viable service probably depends on how long they last, and it's obviously harder to do mail-order than objects would be, but yeah, that sounds like a good way to advertise and scrape up starter capital. You wouldn't believe the rents on storefronts inside the Avalon. Everybody's so crammed in and many critters don't have the option to just park somewhere else instead, so..."
"If I was no longer human and couldn't hide this, I couldn't keep it from him forever if I wanted to. He doesn't really care what's going on with my life, but every now and then he feels the obligation to check up on me, and he would notice eventually if I moved out and attempted to cut off contact."
"A lot of people who are stuck in Avalaons don't legally exist. They have setups to handle it. My parents are fine and I told Ren everything and will tell Charlie once I can prove it instead of just making bizarre statements of reptilianhood over the phone, but if I didn't and my medallion stopped working..."
"Given that I already legally exist, I suspect it would be more convenient to continue to do so and claim to have a rare, debilitating and contagious illness that means I can't show up in person to things. Also, if my father believes I'm dead, it would be harder to access his money than if he wants to ensure I'm not tempted to let anyone he knows know what happened to me."
"If I sprout six extra legs or something and have to go around like that all the time... well, it might depend on whether any of them have properly opposable thumbs, since that would be important for most of my runecasting-related ambitions. The nice bugbear lady might help me get my excess feet under me, I could try teaching adorable monster children school or something."
"I'd be willing to try, if the obvious problems could be reliably patched. It really would make spell development easier, and if it's prohibitively unpleasant, well, I don't try that again. Although it wouldn't surprise me if it was possible to hire people who wouldn't mind acquiring the ability to turn into an interesting and novel kind of magical creature to test spells for us; some people have high pain tolerances or unusual reactions."
The dictionary has an index by meaning. May looks up runes with the permanent enchantment meaning, draws eight of them at random out on graph paper (consulting the textbook for arrangement and proportion guidelines), and starts carefully drawing the lines between them according to the bizarre principles of derivation to construct a new rune in the middle. This all takes about thirty minutes; she's being very careful.
She does misalign her ruler once, but catches it before she gets very far, erases the mistaken line, and otherwise proceeds methodically enough.
And her rune matches a ninth one that's already in the dictionary. "Ha. Well, that was redundant, but at least I know I did it right? I guess I could go through the entire other-meaning-checking and quantity-checking procedure too and be able to check that against the dictionary too. Or do you want to do it?"
This part takes even longer; she redraws her derived rune on a separate sheet and, via elaborate constructions that she has to read every step of from the textbook, gets four meanings' "pure symbols" derived correctly and one wrong. She checks her work, goes back and does it right, and then confirms that there are no other meanings.
Then she gets to do math. It's all arithmetic, but it's tedious arithmetic; presently she has ratios of the "new" rune's meaning strengths relative to the average of the target meaning's strengths in the deriving eight. These she gets right on the first try, with the help of her school calculator.
"I don't think this one's in here," he says, pleased, flipping through the dictionary.
"Better. She said I could tell you what precisely was so melodramatic about her finding out her species if you were curious, since it would be impractical to keep it from you given that the two of you are likely to interact a non-negligible amount over a long period of time and she's willing to trust my judgement that you won't react in a way she would dislike."
"Apparently her mother was taken advantage of at a party while intoxicated, once. She hadn't been sure, up until that point, that Daphne wasn't biologically her husband's, so she didn't tell her. Most of how she expects people to react that she dislikes--that several people have reacted--is considering the firebird who took advantage of her mother her 'real' father as opposed to the good man who raised her."
"Yes, there's definitely a case to be made either way, but I don't blame her at all for being offended when strangers decide to apply their own assumptions and opinions to her situation without consulting her on how she feels about it. It isn't the word she objects to so much as the implication that she must automatically care about him at all as a person."
"She's actively decided against any form of caring about him she can possibly avoid in response to a bugbear she met early on who implied that her biological father had a greater claim on her than her social father on the grounds that the former was the same kind of critter as her."
"I'm not sure she won't change her mind later on, but she really doesn't consider herself to have any reason to want to know anything about him except for possibly things like family medical history. It would be different, I expect, if she had been conceived as a result of--an open relationship between her parents, or a fertility issue that called for a sperm donor, or some other thing that did not cast aspersions on her biological father's character."
"...Mostly magic. But Ren drove me out to the middle of nowhere Saturday night and I flew around in the dark. Since it could take so long to work out invisibility, you know? And there's been school, my French teacher is delighted that I'm suddenly so interested in the subject and has been very helpful about refining my accent and translating obscure vocab for me with more finesse than the dictionary has. And... that's about it, unless you want to hear that I got around to watching the Merchant of Venice movie that came out last winter."
"I think there's certainly something to be said for stories that provide excellent social commentary for the time they're written but don't generalize well, but in general I completely agree with you. Before I discovered magic I was going to learn Ancient Greek and Latin to fill the time so I could read the originals. I suppose I'll probably still get to it someday, but I don't need to fill my time anymore."
"Casting from scrolls written out in heavy, dusty grimoires--oh, I just had a thought. The book said a spell could determine between different marking methods. It might be possible to make multiple-use scrolls by tracing over the runes with several different types of writing implement."
"Not a really complete one. It seems like what you do if you're going to travel and want to visit an Avalon while you travel is you talk to your own Avalon's elders and council people and see if any of them know, and if they don't they'll call other elders and council people... and apparently it just doesn't come up because monsters don't travel much and nonmonsters can just skip Avaloning on their holidays to Hawaii, which is why they haven't gotten fed up with this and made a complete list. One more for the to-do list, you know?"
"Not specifically. I might develop some, if there was a reason. Perhaps I'll take the opportunity to go to Niagara. That's always worth doing." He smiles. "I still remember the first time I saw the falls--I was six, and we had just come here from Poland. Mother thought it would be a good experience for us. It was amazing."
"Charlie's a cop. Chief of police, for whatever that's worth in a town with like six houses and a snowplow, but still. Likes going fishing and watching hockey and stuff. He's quiet. Ren's a kindergarten teacher and she likes - novelty and exotic spirituality and weird food and travel. She manages to be as embarrassing as a white anime fan with a box of Pocky, 'rediscovering her heritage' - I think it didn't interest her until her parents died and learning about it was no longer the conventional, 'done' thing. She's a scatterbrain, I've been handling things like remembering we're out of butter or that she needs to do the taxes off and on for years."
"Aha. Well. Anything reasonably described as a deity is either not particularly benevolent or it had better be stretched really thin holding the laws of physics together and not have a speck of attention to spare for lamb vindaloo. My life is quite nice, but there are many inexcusable failures of adequacy in the world in general. I have heard that there are critter-like things which do not work like normal critters and are called respectively angels and demons, so I'm not sure I can categorically assume that the role of 'deity' is empty, but I remain as sure as ever that theodicy doesn't resolve in its favor somehow."
"I go to church," he mentions, "because I like the aesthetic and regardless of the presence or absence of a deity Jesus's moral teachings make a lot of sense. Jesus's, specifically, not those mentioned elsewhere in the Bible," he clarifies. "But I'm not attached to the idea of God. Historical evidence suggests that Yeshua ben Jusuf was a real person, and he was neat, but" he shrugs. "I suppose it would be inaccurate to say that I don't care at all if God exists. Even if they were otherwise utterly morally myopic the presence of an afterlife is better than not. But I don't know and I'm not going to make decisions based on the assumption that they are and what you're saying makes sense. I don't know if I absolutely agree with it--if God exists anything could, maybe this is all a pocket in a greater reality set, maybe God-if-they-exist is hampered by a set of rules higher than them--I don't know. The only thing I know for sure is that I don't know. I won't make jokes like that, if it bothers you," he adds.
"I haven't actually read the Bible but I have spent enough time interacting with the sort of sandpaper-personality atheists who do to be tempted to repeat choice Jesus quotes," May remarks. "The jokes about the divinity of lamb vindaloo don't bother me in and of themselves, but my flinch reaction when I hear things like that is, 'is this one of those oddly common people who thinks it's morally obligatory for finite wrongdoing to be punished by infinite torture', or 'do I need to not mention being bisexual this afternoon', etcetera. In the absence of reason to think that from you I will not have this reaction to jokes like that from you."
"...She does think magic is a good recreational conversation topic, and she has good ideas, and she's funny and intelligent and her smile, she has the most beautiful smile. And she hugged me spontaneously at the park and she was so warm and she kissed me after it was over and it was--I think I need to apologize to you for mocking you for running off with Daphne at odd moments to make out, if it felt like that." He rubs his eyes with the heels of his hands. "Jaromira, I have it so bad. I haven't really had anyone but you since we were eleven, and--" he swallows. "I'm scared of--going too fast, or getting clingy, and ruining everything."
"Aww." Jaromira hugs her brother. "It's good that you've got someone other than me. Talk to her if you're worried about messing up. Tell her that you're not good at being close to people, and how exactly you expect that to impact things. If she's really as wonderful as all that, she won't take it too badly as long as you phrase it as 'I'm concerned about your boundaries please help define them more specifically' rather than 'I expect to behave badly.'"
He leans into the hug. "Thank you," he says quietly. "You're--so much better at people than I am." He giggles. "That was one of the things that was funny, even, we joked that extroversion was witchcraft and it ended up with the Inquisition with the comfy chair--you know, from Monty Python--versus the tea we made with the boiling spell and an 'interrogation'."
"I'm fine. I just..." he trails off. "I've always been an introvert, but when my mother died, I withdrew. For almost a year Jaromira was the only other human being I would talk to. I've gotten better since then, obviously, but I'm not good at figuring out what's appropriate or healthy concerning human relationships. ...I don't know if I'm actually in love with you yet, but I seem to be very infatuated at the very least. I do not want to get clingy or pushy or otherwise problematic, but I'm not completely certain where the boundaries are."
She pulls up her own list, quizzes him on why he included the meanings she didn't include, explains the ones she has and he doesn't. The goal is consensus; ideally neither of them is casting a spell that either one thinks has been done wrong.
"Hm. We weren't too far off from each other. What say we go from here and try to work out - a few different ways to diagram a spell out of the meanings, take our time, but not cast it until they do some homework? We don't want to be a statistic. We wouldn't even be accessible enough as a statistic to deter anyone on the margin."
Her spreadsheet is huge. It has rows for runes (page number and letter orderings) and columns for meanings (all the dozens of them). Sorted correctly, it will provide lists of options and their amounts in each meaning for everything on their consensus list.
"You start with 43-B and I'll start with 77-A and we go from there?" she suggests, indicating the most important meaning and two runes that are stronger in that than anything else.
And she gets to work starting from 77-A. It covers two meanings she wants and four she doesn't; she will need to add some things and subtract some things... Scribble scribble.
The water does not boil.
She plays the recording back, and it continues not to boil.
"Okay, so I can not cast by trying not to cast and recordings don't work."
It does not boil.
"Recordings don't work," she says, and she writes that down.
"To be honest, I think magic is a point in favor of there being a deity of some kind, benevolent or not. Physics as a system is self-contained enough for it to make sense as a spontaneous generation; magic seems more arbitrary. But then, people thought that about the natural world before they learned better; I certainly don't consider it proof."
He writes this down. "What else...we're thinking of so many things that are obvious in retrospect, I'm half tempted to go through my room and inspect every single object for potential runic applications. Can you project runes onto a surface with a prism, I wonder, and cast from the projection as long as a human being is holding the prism?"
"I have a reasonable set of clothes that suit my aesthetic and all look good together, so I can just grab whatever comes first to hand in the mornings." Kanimir's aesthetic, based on a bit more than a week's observation, seems to consist mostly of blacks slacks and dark jeans, long jackets, and shirts in various styles and colors, mostly either button-downs or t-shirts with nerdy prints.
"I diiiiiid iiiiiit," she sings when she resumes visibility, wriggling happily. "And that's long enough to do some decent flying, too. We'll see if yours gets better duration."
Kanimir's invisibility is a little better, but not by much--twenty-three minutes forty seconds. He doesn't do something similar to May's own invisible shenanigans, mostly because his sister is standing right there. And because trying to sit in her lap while she was in her wheelchair without her cooperation seems a terrible idea.
"Yes, as it is we have two nearly-redundant spells. Perhaps for our next project we should choose two goals, have both of us draw up a potential set of runes for each one, check them over with each other like we did for this one, and then each of us uses the given runeset for a single task to complete it."
"Hmm. Cold and snakebite, yes, but I think the whole thing had better be more comprehensive overall if cancer is going to be covered as well--snakebite isn't as pervasive and it doesn't matter if you don't get every single pathogen for the common cold as long as you get enough that contagiousness and symptoms cease to be an issue."
"I'm fairly sure you're right, but if I'm going to create a cancer spell I'd rather have one with less of a chance of remission later on than the standard techniques, because if your immune system misses any of the leftover cancer cells they can go somewhere else and start the whole thing over again." He considers. "I suppose it isn't as important as it looks on the surface, though, if the spell will reliably work again if the patient does go into remission; chemo is dangerous in its own right and doesn't always work multiple times, is part of the problem."
"Right. If we can just spend ten minutes copying out a healing spell every time someone's cancer is acting up again, cancer remission is officially less annoying than, like, diabetes. Especially since there's no reason to expect that some things are magically inoperable the way that certain brain cancer might be."
"...Yes," he says. "But it might be worth doing to let some ER workers in on it sooner than that. A few miraculous recoveries probably aren't going to upset things irrevocably. Although it might be worth doing to make a spell that didn't heal someone all the way but could still be used to make sure someone in critical condition didn't die in the next hour."
"I don't mind volunteering some of my time to make scrolls and so on for emergency medical use, and of course there's all the other thing we're planning on selling...I think a permanent invisibility item might be lower on the priority list than things that are safer to mass produce and sell."
"I'm not averse to volunteering either, but we'll need materials and I don't want to live with my mom forever and, frankly, we deserve hazard pay. And there's a question as to whether our time is better spent on R&D versus copying things out - and if it's the former, we will probably need to pay people to copy things out."
"Oh, that's true." He considers. "Maybe on that note we should try to make a spell that detects the early stages of diseases that kill you but take a long time to do it. Like cancer, but not just cancer. Then we could fix those without the medical profession ever coming into it in such a way that leaves a paper trail."
"I was very, very angry. I don't think I quite understood the distinction between being angry at the world for killing my mother and angry at my father for forcing me to be there and angry at the therapist for being there. I did not have a psychologically healthy eleventh year."
"Yes. But it would probably be best not to involve the poor man. The nurses are fine," he adds. "the bite was an isolated incident and I regretted it even before I had gotten the rest of the way out of my shell. And I was much better company while she was convalescing, in any case."
(Although she does make a mental note that if those two get less discreet she does have an ambiguously-defined girlfriend with which to enact Vengeance.)
"He had a new love interest every movie. And most of them weren't of the one-night-stand variety, although I think the one in the second movie may have been." He rolls his eyes. "The first one was explicitly his ex-girlfriend with a grudge because he had been doing that kind of thing for a long time."
"It was how they broke up, I think." He waves a hand. "I could be wrong, I suppose, it's been a while and some of it was subtext. But I do think given the hard feelings from the first breakup they shouldn't have gotten back together if they weren't very sure it was going to work."
"Oh, that reminds me--Kanimir told me about what he told you about Daphne's and my relationship. He misunderstood something. It's not that I'm confused about what my feelings for Daphne are, it's that I've had crushes and I've had platonic friends and it's not that I'm not sure which this is, it's that my feelings are genuinely somewhere between the two."
"Not really! Just, you know, briefly covering stuff like are-we-monogamous that we'd want to go over if we were proper dating, when it's appropriate to refer to each other in what context--we're totally dating if a relative who'd otherwise be pushy about setting us up with someone asks, f'rinstance."
"It probably would be complicated if either of us were having these kinds of feelings at someone who was normal in that respect, but--what was that quote again about finding someone whose weirdness matches yours? Jaromira and I have our weird feelings, and you two," she grins, "have your adorable nerdiness."
"So I'll be quasi-Evil Overlady, you be the shadowy yet extremely competent vizier, Kanimir can be the court magician..." she thinks about this. "Iunno, probably easier if we just make you empress, I feel like you'd rock a crown way better than shadowy vizier robes. Okay, you be Empress, I'll be a Science Advisor on the grounds that I'm totally going to get a doctorate in biology when I grow up, see if I don't, Kanimir can be court magician slash Emperor Consort, and Jaromira can be the court poet if you can find a use for one, she's actually really good."
"Fair enough. And meanwhile you are going to do a ton of magic and I'm going to learn slightly less magic on account of I'm also totally going to get a doctorate in biology and I will totally be your Magic Science consultant. A Magic Science consultant. You are probably also going to need other fields of Science consulted."
"Probably 'take genetic samples and analyze differences between various sorts of critters and humans.' But also possibly things like--I'm a firebird, I have some remarkable visual similarities to a peacock aside from mostly being in reds and oranges, I could see if I'm put together like a peacock too."
May reads, murmuring softly: "My commander could in extremis write runes at random and speak to them as he would a soldier, trusting his touch to guide them away from unwanted magic; if his results were less powerful this way at least they took only moments to achieve, when we found ourselves without our preparations or references... Holy shit."
"I know. It's not anywhere near relevant yet, I suppose, since we don't even know if resurrection is possible yet, and even then finding someone who wouldn't just start the whole mess over again--I suppose just never resurrecting any sphinxes might do it, but I feel somewhat leery of choosing sides in this whole thing, even retroactively--but holy shit."
"That's--you--" he breaks off. "I am retroactively halfway worried about you. If a thing that everyone thinks is true were true then you wouldn't exist. I know it's irrational but my brain is screaming that you had such a close call--and oh my god this is going to be amazing, you can--" he breaks off again. "My brain is halfway screaming with retroactive terror and half with amazed delight. It is very confusing."
"Yes, I approve of a lower risk of getting accidentally smote. I expect Jaromira will still want to check everything, since there's the chance that something harmless and useful to you could have negative side effects for someone else, but frankly even if only you did all the casting I would expect this to speed things up quite a bit."
"I might want to re-carve the tablet a bit before then--repeatedly boiling things on wax is starting to warp it a little bit, I'd like to straighten out the edges. Actually, I think I'd like to get something a little more resilient than wax at some point. But for now a little bit of maintenance will keep it workable."
"Jaromira actually found a recipe for a simple plastic on the internet that should be more durable than wax even aside from the heat thing, so we're going to try that. But perhaps with a different spell, to start; I must admit a slight sentimental attachment to the object with which I cast my first spell."
"I suppose it would be dragonscale after all, if Jaromira ever finds an appropriate dress," Kanimir muses. "Not that we ought to let on. Although I suppose in that case it would be a reference to a secret nobody else would get twice over. ...It's alright for me to tell Jaromira, right? I trust her discretion. Daphne's, too, but if it came down to it I'm much more confident in my ability to keep secrets from her than from my twin."
"It's not - I don't mind being a dragon, or some unfactionated firebird or probable-human knowing that I am a dragon. I just don't want this to turn into a chain of a lot of people being really totally trustworthy up until someone thinks that I'm going to kill their hiding sphinx friend or relative because they don't trust that their friend's boyfriend's brother's friend's sister's friend or whatever says that it's okay and this is a nice dragon, and in such a condition of uncertainty they'd better kill me first. I probably should have asked you if you were comfortable keeping secrets from literally everybody before I said. Although given the timing I bet you could have guessed."
"I can keep secrets from Jaromira in the short term. I don't know about the long term, I've never tried. I expect she'd be more comfortable with it if she believed you'd be alright with her telling Daphne at some point in the future if and when you trusted her more, but I also expect she'd do it regardless."
"I don't know that she'd want to tell anybody. She and Jaromira have friendly acquaintances in the supernatural world, but they're not close to anybody here but each other and arguably us. And it would hardly be relevant to her mundane relatives. Personally, I'm in favor of telling them and swearing them to secrecy to anyone else specifically because they're assisting us with the magic project; no one else is, and it wouldn't be as relevant to anyone who wasn't. And I did say 'if' and when," he shrugs, "and it could be that a prerequisite to trusting her is being sure that she wouldn't tell anyone you hadn't personally vetted and approved. Jaromira isn't impatient, but there's a difference between being asked to keep a secret indefinitely and being asked to keep a secret forever."
"...If you really were a wyvern, the wings-for-arms thing would be sufficiently impeding to dexterity that I doubt my sister would think much of it that you're never in midform. If I come home acting like I have a secret and I tell her it's not mine and I act as gleeful as I'm not sure I can refrain from because all this is awesome, her first guess is likely to be that we had sex and either you didn't want to tell anyone because reasons or I didn't want to tell her because teasing."
"We don't know that I have any awesome powers yet. I may not. What we do know is that it's very easy to lose critter lineages in medallioned families, there could be sphinxes around who hate my guts and are just as likely to have awesome powers, and I may have just permanently failed at infosec that might be preventing me from having magical assassins after my blood."
"...If she guesses, she won't tell. Not anyone. Not if I ask her not to. She may not be as happy as she could possibly be not telling Daphne but she won't." He puts his hand on hers. "I don't think she will guess. And I can not tell her, if it matters to you this much, and if she guesses anyway, she'll come to me before anything else and I'll tell her it matters to not tell anyone and she won't."
"...I don't expect you to trust her as much as I do. But I do trust her, and--I care about you. I don't want you to get hurt. And she knows that, and knows that it would break something if she did something that got you hurt. ...And I can keep it down to normal levels of magic-is-awesome-May-is-awesome-the-
"...I'm sorry. I think it's wonderful and I don't want you to be sorry you told me and I don't want you to be afraid for your own safety and I especially don't want you to have to be afraid for your own safety. And I don't want to pick sides between sphinxes and dragons but if a sphinx starts something I'd pick your side in a heartbeat. And. I want to make this better and I don't know how, I'm not good with people and I don't know if there even is a way to make this better."
"Not particularly. It would have seemed awkward to make some kind of presumption on that level without a similar expectation of introducing you to my father, and I have no idea if or when you'd ever want to specifically meet him. I expect it would happen eventually, but--it's not like we have the kind of relationship where I tell him when things happen to me."
"He's about due to pretend he cares what's going on in my life soon; I'll probably mention you then. It's...possible he will want to meet you. To make sure I'm not seeing someone he'd be embarrassed to be tangentially associated with, most likely," he winces. "If so, I apologize for his behavior in advance."
"I'm gonna go up and show Kanimir the extent to which blue is my color," May says.
"I'll alert the media."
"The tabloids, maybe."
May abandons her chair at the front hall and makes her way up the stairs. It has double banisters.
And when he has sat, she assesses her distance from various walls, and then turns into a dragon.
She is about the size of a large sofa, plus some tail; low, sinuous, horned, ice-blue, with sharp narrow wings folded against her middle.
"Oh, I'd get her to turn me invisible and fly around, obviously," laughs Ren. "I'd be so tempted to tell all my friends, but apparently that would be dangerous! I can get into the Avalon either way, all I have to do is know my stuff for the guards - you know, of course, you don't have a medallion either. Anyway, I can't be turning in the middle of a magic shop and the blank medallions are so expensive, so it'll have to be a daydream for the time being."
"Daphne's the firebird?" asks Ren.
"Yeah. But since critters might all be created by magic it could also have to do with cognitive accessibility - people think about birds more than reptiles? And definitely think about wings more than other aspects of birds, so winged-thises-and-thats are common."
"Daphne has ambitions towards a Ph.D in biology. She thinks there's plentiful unconquered ground, scientifically, in critter biology. The cognitive accessibility notion is intriguing. I wonder...if crittering someone is something that happens by accident sometimes, if it's possible to do it on purpose? Once we have the medallions thing figured out, of course, and using consenting volunteers."
"On a practical if not necessarily academic level...what ought we to do once we graduate high school, come to think of it? It's not like you can study thaumatology in college. If we were more certain there were no extant magic schools it would have to be education, wouldn't it..."
"I enjoyed college but I'm not sure either of you would get along particularly well with education majors or the instructors," Ren mentions.
"And we were thinking we'd teach adults anyway, right? You need less formal training for that than for wrangling a classroomful of kids."
"It helps somewhat that I can just tell myself that of course with potentially all of forever of course I'll accumulate a degree or two eventually but I have to admit I'm slightly jealous of Daphne for having picked out a useful niche that involves getting to put the letters Ph.D after her name. Not enough to want to trade places with her, but some."
"I thought skipping grades would hurt your social development," Ren says.
"And for all I know you were right, but I'm not sure I had enough social development for it to be worth preserving."
"I suppose we're on a similar level, then. I have the advantage of a twin, but even though she's rather social I still tend not to interact with her friends--besides Daphne, who's on a different level--outside the relevant contexts. Sitting with her and whoever else at lunch, for example."
"Well, I don't have the benefit of a sibling, but yeah. Sitting alone at lunch sucks enough that I'll put in the effort to learn names, find Nerd Table, and make polite conversation; having nothing on after school is more bonus than negative so I don't push it farther than that."
"Which one from summer camp?"
"When you were nine, with the certificate, you smiled properly for the camera in that one."
"All right, fine, but you stop there, okay?"
"Okay, okay," laughs Ren, and she goes and gets a photo album and comes back and shows it to Kanimir opened to the correct page. A nine-year-old May displays a certificate next to her beaming gaptoothed face; it asserts that she is an Exemplary Camper. Other photos on the page are May and other kids playing the recorder at some sort of school event, May looking disgruntled in a fishing hat with an out-of-frame father patting her on the head from the right angle to also be taking the picture, and May in line for a roller coaster.
"I call people idiots with regrettable frequency. To start. I have gotten more adept over the years at keeping my mouth shut when I'm tempted to say something no one involved is going to be happy I said, but finding tactful ways of rephrasing often takes longer than it's feasible to pause in a conversation without awkwardness."
Upstairs they go, then! May emails everybody the spreadsheet, plugs her laptop in to charge, and says, "I have some gray copies of the boiling spell if you want to trace one now instead of waiting for tomorrow? To check if I can stop you casting and if so whether I have to be touching you or the water or what."
Kiss! Inconsistently visible kiss! It briefly occurs to Kanimir that it must look really odd when he's invisible, but since they certainly shouldn't have any observers he puts it from his mind. Besides, he's the inconsistently visible one, if anyone toot a picture it would be May that looked silly.
She turns the flashlight on behind the plastic wrap, makes sure nothing is stretched, and presses the face of the light directly against the floor so it's not distorted. She incants to boil the teacup.
"Yeah." May goes and gets a camera. "But a badly designed teleport spell - which will probably turn out underpowered because I'm just canceling the unwanted effects, not funneling all the power into the wanted ones - might leave me without anything except myself, say, and that would be awkward."
"I'm sort of wondering if there might be an effect where casting the same spell a lot makes it easier in some way - there's no really safe way to experiment without my power confounding it, but neither we nor the textbook would necessarily know if a well-used spell is, say, still safe to use if you wobble a line a bit or trip over a consonant. With my power confounding it, aiming at a result I've ever cast for before would be suspect. So I want to test both 'incanting in English' and 'hackjob runes' with new effects. I'll try freezing some water and then melting it but not to a boil."
"I was teasing, obviously magic is better. I... tentatively think it is okay for you to tell Jaromira and for her to tell Daphne provided it goes no farther than that. That I am a dragon. It'll make dividing tasks a lot easier and I'm safer than I thought I was from random aggression."