The bar was...unusually reticent, in the lower layers of her mind (and she hadn't pried further; she wasn't sure if she'd be noticed; she wasn't sure if offending would get her kicked out, and regardless of whether it was actually safe it was safer than anywhere else she'd been for the past...three years?) so she couldn't be sure this place wasn't really a trap of some kind, but the higher layers gave a plausible explanation that didn't involve being a trap, and whatever else it was warm and dry and had food. Her guard was probably a full 25% down. Positively trusting, these days.
Instinctively, she reaches out--assess the threat, optionally neutralize and flee--but there isn't even a mind there, who the fuck is daring to act friendly while wearing one of those damn bastard tinfoil hats they made out of Dad's helmet--
She turns around, a snarl rising on her lips, only for confusion to override rage--she's not wearing a telepathy-blocking hat, or any kind of hat for that matter (if she was wearing any kind of hat there would be no guarantee it wasn't lined) only to be overriden in turn by fear (no matter how she's untouchable she could hurt me at any time how do I escape--)
"I. Don't know how you know me." (maybe she's a mutant maybe she visited the school before everything ended maybe I gave her a kind word and she remembered it in the long dark times since but Bar says she gathers from all kinds of worlds--)
(If there is more than one universe might there be more than one of her it might be a case of mistaken identity
unless that's what they want you to think. You would trust someone an alternate version of you had vetted, wouldn't you, more than a completely random stranger, but you can't trust her you can't read her)
She starts edging around. This place was safer than back home but at least there the only people who can block her can be neutralized by Emily but Emily isn't here--
"I don't think I know you."
"I'm not the fucking supervillain, the supervillains are the people who murdered a school full of children, my parents, literally everyone I have ever loved except my sister, and thousands if not millions of other innocent bystanders. I'm pretty sure you only count as a supervillain when it is significantly less ambiguous that you are the lesser of two evils. I would love to be able to afford to have ethics again, but every day I get to decide between reading some peoples' minds without saying pretty please first and letting not only myself but also dozens of innocents die. If it helps I'm under no illusions that I count as an innocent anymore."
"If there was anyone else who could, I'd gladly step down. If abdicating responsibility didn't mean people died, I'd gladly step down. Do you literally think that mindreading is worse than death, and that you have the right to make this choice for everyone else I interact with?"
"Do you think I think I'm going to make it out of this alive!? I live to protect those in my care. When my purpose is complete, if it ever is, if someday the survivors live in peace and don't have to look over their shoulder lest jackbooted thugs or murderous robots end them, one way or another I'm going to be dead."
"I'm right here, you know, you don't have to talk about me behind my back."
"Fine. What the hell is wrong with you, if you're doing things to other peoples' brains without consent."
"It's a matter of fucking survival! Not just mine! Not just Emily's!"
"Right. And no one else could do something better?"
"Everyone else besides us who could do anything about it is dead. Including our parents."
"Tell me, have you ever spent five minutes trying to think of alternate solutions besides turning into my worst nightmare?"
"Of course I fucking have!"
"Really trying? Or convincing yourself that it was necessary, that you had to play the martyr no matter how much it hurt other people? Because it hurts, because it can never stop hurting no matter what, and nothing really matters, even the people you're supposed to be protecting?"
"What--you can't imagine--the Hell I live in--I call my worst nightmares Tuesday--"
"Funny enough, lying to yourself doesn't work as well to an external self."
Ambiguously-evil Edie's head is lowered, and she's shaking. "You can't--I can't..."
Cerebella looks at her, and--
Puts down the Psyche staff against a wall.
"I'm not defenseless even without this," she warns, as the desperate one looks up sharply. "Touch anything private and you'll regret it."
After a moment, the desperate one--
collapses like a puppet with cut strings.
"...She couldn't let herself believe me if she didn't have a look for herself. I don't actually mind having my mind read in principle, so I let her. She's currently trying to reconcile I've been being willfully blind for the past three years with and this led me to do terrible things with and collapsing into a heap of self-loathing and/or suicide is the opposite of helpful," Cerebella murmurs. "...I'm so, so, tempted to just--blame everything she did on the people who hurt her, but it doesn't work like that, does it." She shivers. "I just hate to think--that I could have ended up like that. I wouldn't," she whispers fiercely to herself. "I wouldn't do that. Not me. Not now."
"...What do you think we should do with her? I imagine she's not going to leave Milliways until she's come up with something better than what she previously had, but...even if she was handling it badly, I'm still not comfortable just throwing her back into whatever broke her."
"Depending on how long you're interested in staying to help she could probably get it before it would be a problem that she didn't have it even if she didn't get it to start. ...Although...maybe it would be a good idea to chuck her through my door now, if she agrees to it. Take advantage of the personal achievement boosts from figuring out how to put herself back together." She nibbles her lip. "It's a gamble, if it turns out she puts herself back together badly and then she has this power, but it could have a high payoff if it worked out."
"Yeah...I mean, it's unlikely that she's going to come out of this doing something worse than what she was already doing. I, uh," she winces. "I got a look at what she could do when she checked my sincerity. She...was actually showing nonzero restraint. Not that this excuses what she did, but..."
"...Okay," Cerebella murmurs to Bella after a bit, "so, she's less, um, repentant than I had guessed, possibly to preserve what's left of her sanity, but she's perfectly willing to never do that again if I make her my kind of magical girl because if she works hard and manages to come up with a resurrection spell it is theoretically okay for anything to be okay ever again, basically. Also that kind of communication felt a little like the fluff's, but more...comprehensive."
She addresses her alt. "No offense, but so far our only interactions--on that level--were under your control. If you want me to decide to throw you at even more power than whatever it is you have--well, there's an obvious thing that it would be a touch hypocritical to object to, but of course you do, regardless, have the right to withhold consent."
"Mmkay." Mind Mirror! She steps inside.
"...I'm sorry," the other one offers after a moment. "I was. Um. I shouldn't have even tried and I'm sorry."
"I wasn't doing it because I wanted to. I'm--I'm not saying that makes it okay, but I was a traumatized teenager making terrible choices because trauma, not--a mustache-twirling villain who'd keep on doing it even if--" she glances worriedly at the mirror. "That's why I want more options."
"Okay." Pause. "When I first realized there was someone there and I couldn't even tell your mind existed I thought you were--one of the people who was trying to kill me because--back home there's only one thing that can do that. It's an alloy. The only amount of it anyone knows to exist comes from a helmet my dad had before they killed him. So. I--I don't know, I don't even know why I'm telling you this..." her hands are trembling.
"...Part of it is that she's not likely to resort to unethical things when she has better options, part of it is...she thinks she can work up to a resurrection spell at some point, at which point she gets to answer to her version of Dad for any nonconsensual mindreading she did and Dad isn't fond of it either. Like, a lot of her terrible decision making is predicated on 'nothing can ever be okay again' and now she has evidence that it is theoretically possible for anything to be okay ever again, and damn is the inside of her brain a depressing place."
"In the wake of one of the rescues, I actually ended up talking to Prismatic Waterfall Legend about my ideas, and she's a Middle Eastern immigrant to the US, so she's been dealing with that level of social bull, and she said she could probably get me in touch with Mystical Mirror Madchen, who's from a family a lot like mine in the sense of 'recent ancestors came over because German Jewish and Holocaust,' although I think hers got out beforehand whereas apparently Grandpa Jake had a number tattooed on his arm. Anyway. It was suggested that I'd have more effect if I started out working on one issue and made some significant ground on it before trying to organize a major intersectional group rather than just running around talking to people with nothing to back it up. So with any luck I'm going to talk to her soon and we can discuss strategy for dealing with anti-semitic problems--you probably haven't had this happen yet, but there's some really scary shit going down in France-for-example--and I haven't actually met her yet so I can't plan out for sure where exactly it goes from there."
Handsqueeze. "Sometimes I just want to take over the world because I could run it better, but then I remember that that's the best way to get branded a villain, thwarted by my peers and with a severely damaged ability to persuade other people to stop being terrible."
"So, the internet is when computers get really cheap and popular and can call each other on the phone only better. So if you assemble some information or write a story or take pictures or whatever you can put them on a computer and all the other computers can get ahold of it at any time. It is even cooler than it sounds."
"...Okay, so I'm a mutant. Most mutants aren't telepaths, but we usually have powers of some kind. A rogue faction of the government got scared enough of us to develop murder robots, kidnap my shapeshifter aunt to--augment their adaptability somehow, I don't know--and decide to wipe us out, and incidentally conquer the country since otherwise they'd be fugitives for mass murder. Things...sort of escalated from there."
"I did mean it about keeping an eye open. This whole mess started five years ago, and until two years later we had plans to fix this. And then they found us and killed almost everyone who was left and it was all Emily and I could do to grab a handful of the littlest ones and flee. I promise, if I had reason to think there was anything in particular that would work I would have been on it like a starving man on a sandwich."
"I'm--trying to think of something to say that doesn't sound unnecessarily--conflict-starting. I--I don't blame you for being upset at the--misjudgement I've been making. That's perfectly reasonable. But I've kept six small children alive for three years while we're chased by genocidal robots, and it--hurts my feelings when you look down on me for not also creating a viable plan to solve the entire problem."
"I'm in a time loop. Whenever I die or deliberately reset, I wake up in the hospital having recently been hit by a van in miraculously perfect health. I haven't gotten any farther than a month past that because that's when the giant monster gets too big and eats the world."
"I mean, mutants behave in ways that seem to break conservation of energy all the time, if someone told me my brain slash emotions broke conservation of energy somehow I'd probably be slightly smug rather than any kind of disbelieving but just normal people's? Maybe we ought to rethink this whole conservation of energy thing."
"Neither do I. I'm not desperate to be your kind of magical girl, just acknowledging the possibility. ...Although if we wanted to make her both kinds of magical girl I suspect that doing yours first would be the better idea. I don't think it's a coincidence that you got what you got first and not something, I don't know, time-related."
"...I mean, you probably wouldn't have had a problem with my sister if you'd met her instead, except insofar as she's been condoning my behavior by not forcing me to stop somehow and/or leaving. It seems to me like the problem is less quantity of power and more type, so as long as I don't just get more telepathy I'm not sure it's relevant. And, also, falling too far into the despair pits, but I know to guard against that this time."
"Fluffs and girls operating on the orders of fluffs trying to steal my gem, much faster response time replacing any given fluff I killed, fluffs speculating about how I must have managed to make my wish when they don't remember it, eventually they amassed superior firepower that I did not manage to take a photo of before I reset."
"Hebrew! My first thought was that I could finish my letter to Mystical Mirror Madchen, and my second thought was that if I could convince the translation effect to cooperate I could work on my Hebrew, and then I realized that I could probably get documents from Bar in Hebrew from before Hebrew was an exclusively religious language. There's even some stuff in the Old Testament that people aren't quite sure how to translate because of hapax legomenontry or however you modify that word--"
"Lots of reasons. Partly it's because stories about my family specifically are...kinda thin, after the Holocaust, and our history is a way of connecting to the people my grandparents lost. Partly it's to spite everyone who ever tried to wipe us out. Partly it's because I think Hebrew is beautiful."
"Yep. Possibly less generic since her family came over from England only a couple of generations ago--one time when someone was asking me for my ethnicity in a particularly obnoxious way I identified as 'half Anglo-Saxon half Ashkenazi'--but for all intents and purposes yes."
"Alas. On the other hand, I don't exactly take French class seriously but I do care about my grades enough to pretty much learn the material, and there's been some songs on the curriculum. Caaan I see a, um, songbook that has Lark, At the Point of Avignon, and, um, the one that goes At the clear spring, as I strolled by, I found the water so beautiful, that I bathed myself."
"...I think I had better not," the other one says after a moment of looking incredibly conflicted. "Differences and...stuff. Um. I'll just...do the magic thing and then flee like a coward, probably."
Her world. It can only be hers, of the three, because it's dotted with minds of a familiar kind--mutants. Too few, far too few, and more winking out all the time as the Sentinels reap their bloody work.
The image dissolves, and reforms--one of the deadly metal creatures, looming over a screaming woman. A barrier springs up between them. Protection, murmurs a voice from nowhere.
Another Sentinel, shifting rubble out of the way to reach the young boy it was shielding, raising an arm to--crush him, or spear him through the chest, or something. It halts, shuddering--and collapses in on itself. Vengeance, the voice whispers. (She hates herself, a little, because she has gotten to the point where that sounds more appealing.)
She sees herself, older, wiping out a horde of them with a single magical blast. She sees others. She sees her sister, in an outfit not much less ridiculous than the one her alt had been wearing. She sees a girl with purple skin being offered a similar choice.
I will follow you, the voice murmurs. Your people need not be powerless. You can be the vanguard of a new era. A leader, as those before you were, and would have continued to be. You are not broken beyond repair.
She sees herself, laughing, face lined with past grief but not so overburdened by it that she cannot walk forwards.
"Fear, devourers of kin! Flee, evildoers unto the innocent! The Rose of Defiance is come, and there is no promise of mercy for the spillers of blood in her heart!"
And she goes outside, holding the door long enough to invite followers, if they want to see the magic thing. In addition to the lake, there is a forest, and a mountain off in the distance. Rose of Defiance decides to position herself such that if she just fires off a random energy blast or something it will just go harmlessly into the sky. And her spell is...
Flip-the-grip-on-the-whips arms folded over chest back of the hands out "Flowerstorm Barrage!"
Gosh. That sure is a lot of rose petals going at an awfully high velocity. In a lot of colors, too, which is odd given that the roses on her wrists are just red.
"I don't even know if they'd have any idea what was happening if they suddenly started experiencing an emotion, come to think of...it...it is potentially possible that I could actually do that and my brain started generating reasons why trying would be a terrible idea the moment it crossed my mind and hasn't stopped yet."
"I'm a malcontent. People in general are not disposed to calmly discussing and amending their beliefs, even if those beliefs harm others. Authority figures don't take well to 'insubordinate' kids, even when they're being dicks. And sometimes teenagers do it on purpose because they think it's funny."
"Hello. My name is Charlotte, and this is my husband Erik. Edie tells us you're a completely different kind of magical girl with a rather unfortunate home situation. What did you do before saving the world from deceptively fuzzy aliens and the results of their evil emotion-vampire system?"
"Uh, I just got a mind defense spell, so I guess the things that could most easily take me out at this point would be prolonged separation from my body, excessively informed fluff shenanigans with unfamiliar magic to counter or alter mine, and non-magical methods of mind-warping which don't admit suicide as an escape hatch for some reason."
"I don't know if it's come up, but our world has more kinds of magic than just magical girls. I'm a sorcerer. I can't say I know enough about fluff magic to usefully counter it, but I do know of spells to keep one from being separated from individual belongings and as a sort of magical poison tooth."
"I am so, so sorry for not thinking of it," Edie winces. "What else is my brain trying to overlook...it's possible, if you're willing to spend some time in our world, that we could get you an artifact. The process is bureaucratically painful and you have to consent to having a powerful lie-detecting artifact used on you but there is the possibility."
"It might not be worth the risk for me to leave Milliways, I don't know what it will do to, you know, time," says Bella. "Is 'time' so much time that it would be unrealistic to have people from your world holding the door constantly? And what's unpleasant about becoming a sorcerer?"
"It...might be. I'd say definitely not, considering the state of your world, if you were guaranteed to be approved and get something actually useful, but you're not. Becoming a sorcerer basically involves having your sensory organs burned out and simultaneously replaced with versions capable of perceiving magic."
"It might or might not. Normal painkillers don't work at all, and if you try becoming a sorcerer while unconscious it just doesn't work. It's possible that your innate magic pain switch could work where mundane painkillers and a handful of magical girls and sorcerers have failed, but I wouldn't count on it too hard."
"Well, the thing is I don't have any sensory organs on," she gestures at her gem, "my actual body, and if I don't want my body to talk to me any more I can tell it to cut it out, and I can specify that as far as 'pain', or just turn it way down if I need the heads-up."
"It's possible that that would fail for the same reasons as unconsciousness, or that it might just plain not work for some reason--but I don't know that I would expect it to. If you want my advice, if you're absolutely not willing to deal with a large amount of pain, don't do it. If you're willing to take a risk of dealing with a large amount of pain where you wouldn't accept a sure thing--then go for it."
"Of course, translation becomes an issue if we intend to take any of this home with us. Unless, I suppose, I read all of it while I'm here and transcribe it in English to a computer...or just enough to form a working Rosetta Stone...I suppose that much at least is doable."
"Cerebro--Mom's artifact--doesn't just work on computers and other tech. Technically, it works on any sufficiently complex information system. Which includes brains. She's never read anyone's mind without their knowledge and consent, though, and we keep it secret because there are a lot of people who wouldn't believe she doesn't read everyone's mind who crosses her path. But it seems like the kind of thing where you'd rather be told than find out that I had been keeping it a secret from you later on."
"The bar can sell us the Lost Knowledge of the Ancients in exchange for Bella's infinite counterfeit money. Bella also wants to be a sorcerer, and the Lost Knowledge of the Ancients has something to make that not hurt. I'm going to fetch Cerebro so I can transcribe the stuff so it makes any sense at all once we leave," Charlotte explains, brushing past him.
Charlotte turns it on and pokes at it to make sure she has a good idea of what corresponds to what. "And...I have no idea how to meaningfully ask for the Lost Wisdom of the Ancients. Obviously there's too much literature produced by an entire civilization to to reasonably fit inside a bar."
A moment after that, her magical girl magic presents her with a new spell.
"Dearheart, why don't you get some introductory sorcery books from Bar, and you can read them and compile a curriculum for Bella, and I can eavesdrop and transcribe what you're reading? That seems most efficient. And--perhaps we could get a room or something, having a large number of books spread out over the countertop seems unnecessarily obstructive."
"Over the past couple of weeks Dad's been called on to demolish a condemned building, move a tree that couldn't have been mundanely transplanted without killing it, immobilize a broken leg bone so the kid didn't have to get a traditional cast, and clean out a chunk of lake that someone had been dumping garbage into. Last month he and a couple of others worked together to renew the city's darkscreen. Um, that's a one-way shield over a city that prevents the light pollution from getting out and confusing bats and birds and stuff. I guess you don't have those, huh."
"Theoretically could have, but--Dad's not really a great healer. He's better than nothing, but for something like a broken leg you want to go to a specialist who'll make sure you won't be feeling rainstorms in it when you're sixty. But specialists like that often have waiting lists, so the kid had to do with a magical pseudo-cast for like a week until he could get to one."
"Skill, inclination, personality--other stuff. Short version is Dad isn't one because trauma. He's--actually really good when it's an emergency, his mind goes sort of cold and clear, and he can do some damn impressive stuff when he's like that--Mom doesn't even have a scar, and she got shot in the lower spine once. Which...was kind of a good thing, actually, because when sorcerers and artifact users associate a particular state of mind with a magical action too much, the magic can start feeding back in on it and creating a loop. The clear cold thing sort of kicked him out of the one he was in. ...I didn't think it was relevant because it's really, really rare, and frankly you're...pretty much the opposite of the kind of person it happens to. Your notebook thing, specifically," she clarifies. "It's the kind of thing that happens when you don't pay attention to your emotions even as much as normal people do, most of the time."
"They happen when a sorcerer or an artifact user has a specific strong emotion, and feeds that emotion into the use of magic--the way you'd feed anger into a punch, basically, or joy into a dance or affection into a kiss--on a regular basis. And then you start feeling that emotion a little more often, in a way that makes you want to do magic with it, and then that makes you feel the emotion more often, which makes you want to do more magic with it, and this basically usually ends either with you snapping out of it and being careful about doing magic while feeling that emotion for a while, your friends knocking you over the head and dragging you to a therapist--I'm being metaphorical here--or dressing in melodramatic cloaks and hiring henchpersons and getting thwarted by other magic users. If it's a negative emotion, anyway, the worst that happens if you feedback on a positive emotion is that you get annoyingly chipper, but positive emotions are harder to let get out of control anyway."
"...Okay," she says after a few minutes. "If for some reason you're ever in my world, some magic users can tell various ways if you're a sorcerer or not, and some villains prefer to target them specifically--usually 'join me or die' kinds of things. Don't try healing someone with a spell you're not sure you have down unless it's enough of an emergency that fucking them up even worse won't make much of a difference. A sorcerer spell, I mean, so far as I can tell magical girl spells don't have failure modes like that. In fact, don't do any spells you're not sure you have down unless damaging the target is an acceptable outcome. You can practice spells in your head without actually casting them. If you have a spell down but you think you'll have it down even better later you might want to wait--fixing something perfectly that's been fixed imperfectly is much, much harder than fixing something from normal broken."
"Not usually, I don't think, but I was always a very extracurricular sort of kid. My parents would probably have homeschooled my sister and I if I didn't insist on sticking around to, well, try and fix the system from inside. And Emily insisted on sticking with me."
"...I mean, in an infinite multiverse I guess it would make sense that some worlds would happen to turn out basically the same way despite fantastic odds against, and given the premise of Milliways in the first place being attracted to superficially similar worlds makes sense."
"Like - with time, you have a system where it's now and now it's some amount later, with space you have a system where there's here and there's a ways off to the left, etcetera, but you couldn't be like 'Bella's world is yea earlier and this much off to the left of Edie's world' in any numerical sense where you could define all the intermediate points along that line."