But if you are Bella and the Valar wiped your memory you would still have an r I think.

"...like I said, I don't acknowledge having forgotten you."

"This conversation is weird."

"He's telepathic or something. I'm going to freak out about that later. Because alien."

You look like Bella and the teleport was aimed for Bella.

"I don't know who that is. I'm Pelape."

"This is just like Friends From Katme."

"It is not like Friends From Katme."

- cling. Then where is Bella.

"...I don't know, because I don't know who that is."

And here is a tinier little child crying in a beautiful cluttered room somewhere and here is a woman who looks a lot like Pelape but brown-haired, appearing out of nowhere and stumbling and catching herself and blinking and looking around in confusion, and here is Fëanáro explaining that she is in the palace, which alarms her, and here is Fëanáro hiding in her guest room a while later and climbing out to demand to be taught how to read -

"...okay, she looks like me, except the hair -"

I can't see your hair and I'm saving my mana to leave, is there a light?

"Sofa, can you get the light?"

"You get the light."

"Sofa, I have an alien on my lap."

Sofa gets the light.

Blink blink. Yeah okay you look just like Bella except the hair. You have Teleri hair.

"What's that?"

His species comes in Teleri (brown or silver or bronze), Noldor (black or red), Vanyar (blonde). 

"...okay. Where did you come from?"

Valinor.

"Where is that?"

Another world.

"Okay, but around what star?"