Accept our Terms of Service
Our Terms of Service have recently changed! Please read and agree to the Terms of Service and the Privacy Policy
Magic Survey on Iwami
+ Show First Post
Total: 53
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

"Well, there are - probably in theory infinitely many actually, but surely at least a thousand at an absolute lower bound meaningfully distinctive ways for magic to work- I, um, read a lot? And the worst writing sin that I cannot tolerate is characters who use magic stupidly!"

Permalink

Hammond nods sympathetically.

"It is, if anything, worse when people use magic stupidly in real life," he agrees. "Would you prefer a system of magic that's hard to misuse, do you think? Such as one that operates purely in the background, not subject to any one person's manipulations?"

Permalink

"That's... No, then there's no choice going into it at all, is there? My problem is- Okay, so there's this one book where the hero gets, basically, weather and terraforming magic. There's a lot of things you can do with that, a great clanhold with year-round perfect weather, a caravanner who passes arid plain and mountain pass with equal ease, or a shipmaster who the wind and waves always love. You could trade, you could build alliances, you could help people- And this character uses it for revenge. In the stupidest, short-term-est possible ways. Summoning storms and breaking the earth into crags upon their enemies. Which generates more enemies. Instead of the - simplest, leanest gesture of cooperation, it's like this one person took it upon herself to burn down as much of the commons as she possibly could. Paranoid bitch. But she was the one with magic, wasn't she, so it's not like anyone could stop her... Which I think is maybe the point of the story in the end. Individual power can lead to ruin."

Total: 53
Posts Per Page: