"Has this ever actually happened yet?"

"Yes, there were lots of them on the continents that sunk."

"And you couldn't get them back if you wanted to?"

"No. Nor can I preserve the others - there isn't anything to them beyond the trees they are."

"Of all the places to find physicalism. Okay. I didn't run into any hobbits, were there hobbits?"

"I don't think they've awakened yet, no."

"Do they have an afterlife setup picked out?"

"I think they're like Men in that no one knows."

"Am I missing anybody? Are werewolves just like Men?"

"Yes. I do not think you are missing anyone."

"Those who died on the Ice I am prepared to release into exile, if they had no part in the Kinslaying. Those who did take part in the Kinslaying have seen themselves only profit from it."

"Many societies get along with punishments lighter than exile for deaths less motivated and more permanent than those your" prisoners "guests caused."

"They introduced an unspeakable horror into Valinor and marred the peace of the Blessed Realm forever."

"Would you like me to solve this problem with time travel?"

"Yes."

"...I was not expecting that answer. I haven't wielded the time stone before so I don't know if I'd be able to finesse it very precisely - I'm getting excellent results with space, just barely passable with reality. If you will reembody the Kinslayers I am willing to try the time stone and see where it can get me on this problem without unpalatable results."

"If the Kinslayers were not guilty of a crime I would reembody them."

That is not the order of operations she suggested. "So you're just planning to keep them forever unless I roll them back to a more innocent state."

"No, eventually they will have served their sentence."

"When's 'eventually'?"

"Two Ages, maybe three."

Put.