"...suppose you would care to explain what you were thinking."
"He started it, Commander."
"...From the inside of a cell."
"He was — smiling, like he was proud of what he'd done—"
Irabeth doesn't say anything to that, just keeps staring at him.
"...and so I figured I could wipe that stupid grin off his face. I didn't think it would be a big deal."
"Had you somehow forgotten the Eagle Watch's standards for the treatment of prisoners, or did you decide they were unimportant?"
"...I figured you had to make them really strict if you didn't want guys going after the pretty ones. I didn't think you really meant every little detail."
"I see. Is there something else I could have said to make it clear that I expected you to follow the standards I specifically ordered you to follow?"
"No sir."
"Do you understand now why this is a 'big deal'?"
"Because you were counting on my smites?"
"That is one reason, yes. It is not the only reason." She pauses. "If we want people to be willing to surrender to our custody, or for that matter to turn over other people they care about to our custody, they need to trust that we will actually abide by the standards of treatment we've committed to. The Goddess chose you as her paladin because she thought you could be trusted with that responsibility. I chose you to supervise the prisoner because I thought you could be trusted with that responsibility. As you may have surmised when the Goddess revoked her blessings, clearly we were mistaken."
The crusader looks down at his hands. "I understand, sir."
"Considering the circumstances, I am authorizing a stay of the bulk of your punishment for the next few days. However, I am adjusting your responsibilities in light of your demonstrated inability to follow simple orders. Report to Ser Dathe in the yard. And tell the other two to speak with me in" (she glances at Blai) "half an hour."
The crusader scampers off.
"My apologies for keeping you waiting, Select. Report?"