Lúthien in Rewind
Next Post »
« Previous Post
+ Show First Post
Total: 3315
Posts Per Page:
Permalink

Keep in mind that we only got one version of the story, because they're not allowed into Doriath. But they decided they wanted to come to our continent from the Valar's continent, and they were in a hurry and they didn't want to build boats, so they stormed a harbor and threw people off the boats into the sea and then people tried to stop them from taking the boats and they got away with the boats but they killed more than ten thousand people. And the Valar were furious and prophecied that only evil would come of their deeds, and that's the Doom. 

Permalink

...prophesied this prescriptively or descriptively?

Permalink

It's the Noldor who told us all this, the Valar have been securing their continent and the Sun and the Moon and they didn't tell my mother anything. So I am not sure. And they're the Valar, they can see outside time, so there's not really any difference. You can't see things you'd have the power to change. 

Permalink

Well, I suppose in that case it could be interpreted as a polite warning. Why did the Noldor want to be on your continent?

Permalink

They didn't want to answer to the Valar, wanted to be in charge. And they'd sworn a terrible oath to kill anyone who stole their jewelry and the Enemy stole their jewelry. 

Permalink

...okay then.

Permalink

We've only heard their side of the story. And only some of them. Most of them aren't allowed in Doriath because of the massacre and because they're kind of rude and very arrogant and make my father nervous.

Permalink

I keep hearing that various people are not allowed in Doriath. It's amazing you get any news at all.

Permalink

Remember what I said about my father being overprotective and paranoid? And the Enemy having unknown mind control abilities?

Permalink

Once the war's over we'll let everyone in. I can't wait. Except maybe the Noldorin leaders who gave the orders for the massacre, we might never ever invite them to dinner.

Permalink

Seems reasonable.

Permalink

Several of my cousins died in it. Dad's little brother ruled the harbor kingdom. I've never met them but it still hurts. 

Permalink

I'm sorry.

Permalink

I also kind of selfishly resent them for it because it made my father so sad and angry when he heard, and that makes him less reasonable.

Permalink

How does that manifest?

Permalink

He, uh, kicked out all the Noldor including some of my cousins' children who I really liked, and then banned the speaking of their language.

Permalink

...their language? What's that have to do with anything?

Permalink

I mean. I don't agree very much with my father. But the Noldor had come over and declared large sections of the continent their kingdoms, and the locals their subjects - they were very nice about it, they could defend people against the Enemy, people were happy to call them Kings in exchange for safety - and they grew up in Valinor, you know, most Elves are nomadic and the Noldor have stone and metalworking, most Elves remember their history in song and the Noldor invented a way of putting words on paper, they have sophisticated magic and good weapons and armor - it was very asymmetrical. And the King's ban meant that at least they have to conduct all of the business of their new courts in a language that their new subjects speak. So I think it had some good effects.

Permalink

Okay, but why is anybody obeying the ban on the language?

Permalink

Their new subjects obey it because they respect my father, and they obey it because otherwise their new subjects would refuse to associate with them.

Permalink

Huh. I suppose it's not the weirdest thing ever proposed as colonialism harm-reduction.

Permalink

Colonialism harm-reduction?

Permalink

The whole 'better educated more advanced people move in and lord it over everyone' thing is called colonialism, it happens here. If a third party obliges the colonists to work in the language of the colonized that could indeed do something to mitigate some of the effects people object to.

Permalink

I will tell him you said so.

Total: 3315
Posts Per Page: